Junior Loni Taylor was chosen from a field of eight girls and crowned Miss St. Johns; sophomore Caroline Robbins was first runner-up, sophomore Jean Marie Maierhoffer was second runner-up, and freshman Eden Benton was third runner-up. Other contestants included: Margaret Jeng, Sarah Hartley, Brooke Lucas, and Ashley Schopp.

The pageant was emceed by junior Franklin Ritch, and senior Lexi Buchanan, Miss St. Johns 2010. The announcer was the current Mr. St. Johns, Patrick Glenn. The proceeds, which exceeded $3,000, will go to benefit the Ashley Cowie Memorial Scholarship Fund. Special guests included Amy Cowie, Ashley’s sister, and Tyler Denning who performed a song he wrote in memory of Ashley, a 2009 St. Johns graduate.